New England Tahk

[cos]

From a coworker:

My mother who had a career as a school psychologist, moved to Southern Maine in her forties, having lived in Cincinnati since girlhood. Early on, she was testing a kid, and asked him, "Can you tell me what a hat is?"

The kid answered, "A haht? A haht's what beats in your chest!"

The thing is, when I tell that story to native New Englanders, they don't get it. "That's a perfectly good answer for a kid!"

Comments

[rmd.livejournal.com]

"Are you a narc?"

[pseydtonne.livejournal.com]

Why no, I'm not a NOC.

[pseydtonne.livejournal.com]

Wait, something doesn't jive here.

If she's from Cincinnati, she would've said 'hæt' aloud. A New Englander reading this would think of the sound 'h/ah/t'. However the Cincy lady would have spoken it, not written it.

I lived in Boston for a dozen years. I know pronunciation differs. However you're suggesting that aural parsing differs.

I understand this with Long Island accents, where they say "Mary, merry, and marry" differently but us upstate New Yorker cannot hear a difference. It took me a year of Nassau County jagovs laughing at me before I realized they nasalized two of them (the ones without the 'e') and had this vowel stretch on the Virgin's name.

Do Bostonians think "hat" and "heart" are homophones? I never noticed anything that extreme. How would they honor the flag at the opening of sporting events?

[mindways]

Do Bostonians think "hat" and "heart" are homophones? I never noticed anything that extreme.
I've known a tiny handful of people with accents that *strong*, but I don't think they were in that particular direction. (Closer to "hot" and "heart" being homophones? Though not all the way there?)

But accents can vary a great deal based just on where in the Boston area you are (I once read something which described how they'd migrated around since the mid-to-late 1800s; I wish I could find it again); the stereotypical "pahk the cah in Hahvahd Yahd" accent exists, but is a pretty small % of the metro-area population. A Southern Maine accent might well be nowhere near Bostonian.